Name: Procopio's Pizza & Pasta
Price range: $$

Procopio's Pizza & Pasta Information

If you're ever in Vincennes, Indiana, and find yourself craving delicious Italian comfort food, Procopio's Pizza & Pasta should be your first stop. Located at 127 N 2nd St, this local gem offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that's perfect for a casual dinner with family, friends, or even a quiet solo meal.

The menu is packed with a mouth-watering selection of pizzas and pasta dishes that cater to every taste. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or something a bit more unique, like their signature meatball pizza, Procopio's has something to satisfy. The crust is always perfectly baked-crispy on the outside, soft on the inside-and the toppings are always fresh and plentiful. For those who prefer pasta, their spaghetti, lasagna, and fettuccine alfredo are all standout dishes, each prepared with a rich, flavorful sauce that complements the perfectly cooked pasta.

One of the best things about Procopio's is the consistency. Every time you visit, you know you're going to get the same high-quality food, which is a testament to the care and attention the staff puts into their cooking. The service is friendly and efficient, and there's something about the cozy, low-key vibe of the place that makes you feel right at home. The staff always goes the extra mile to make sure your dining experience is enjoyable, whether it's offering a suggestion from the menu or checking in to make sure you're happy with your meal.

For those who like to pair their meal with a drink, Procopio's has a solid selection of wines and beers to complement your dish, whether you're enjoying a glass of red with your pizza or a cold beer with your pasta. The casual, unpretentious ambiance makes it an ideal place for a laid-back dinner, but if you're in the mood to celebrate, the staff is more than happy to help make your evening special.

What really sets Procopio's Pizza & Pasta apart, though, is its connection to the Vincennes community. It's the kind of place where locals gather to unwind after a long day, and it has become a favorite for its consistency and the personal touch the owners bring to every meal. Whether you're a regular or a first-timer, you'll always feel like you're a part of the Procopio's family.

If you're in Vincennes and craving some comfort food that's both delicious and comforting, Procopio's Pizza & Pasta should be at the top of your list. The food, the service, and the atmosphere all come together to make it a must-visit spot for anyone in the area.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

We visited around 6pm on a Wednesday and got seated immediately. Parking was easy to find. Service was very quick and attentive. Everyone working was very nice. Prices were super reasonable. Tons of great looking menu options. I don't think a vegetarian would struggle to find a meal here. Vibes were homey and comfortable, especially on such a gloomy rainy day. We had a veritable feast: we ordered beer and two of the day's special $3 margaritas (insane deal), the bosco sticks appetizer (nostalgic, soft, and the perfect vehicle for their pizza sauce), a caesar salad (with beautiful shaved parmesan on top), a cheese pizza (with flavorful sauce and a crust that dreams are made of), the calamarata pasta entree with garlic bread (you have to get some kind of crusty bread to dip in that magical creamy/cheesy/tomatoey sauce), and for dessert we split some of the very rich and decadent chocolate confusion cake (the rest of which is now whispering sweet nothings to us from a takeout box in our fridge). Everything was fresh and delicious and we could not stop talking about what a good choice it was to drive nearly two hours from home just to try it. We were stuffed and on the verge of needing to be rolled out of the establishment because we simply could not stop eating everything at our table. In the end, though, we were able to muster up the strength to walk out on each of our own two feet with just a few pieces of pizza and that fabulous chocolate cake as our trophies from an evening well spent. You won't regret a trip here! Unless you tend to regret eating really good food. In which case, I'm very sorry for your weird hangups, but you should visit Procopio's anyway.

Met a friend for lunch two days ago. I had not tried their flatbread appetizers, so I grabbed the sun-dried tomato pesto one for us to split. It was delightful, with the balsamic glaze adding just a hint of sweetness against the savory tomato pesto and mozzarella base. We went on to grab lasagna, which was fantastic (and reheated well as leftovers). Our meeting ran a bit over, but the servers were incredibly gracious and didn’t rush us out. If you eat off the lunch menu, the price point isn't bad, but we were splurging a bit and chose from the regular appetizers/entrees. Thus, our bill didn’t accurately reflect the lunch prices. No complaints. I always enjoy dropping in or grabbing takeout from here.

Our family went there and were blowin away by the kindness of the staff right away! Our server Colin helped us get our kids settled in an we started of with Delicious cheesy bread! Then we ordered the stuffed pizza. I’ll give it a 10 out of 10! I would recommend this place to anyone! If you’re looking for good pizza or pasta in Vincennes this is your place!!

Great food!! Finally made it in after many years of living in the area. We went for the stuffed crust and that’s what we got. The Procopio’s Supreme and it was supreme. Sweet sauce , loaded down with pepperoni, home made sausage, peppers, olives, onions, and an abundance of mozzarella. Great beer list if you don’t want wine or mixed drinks. Will be back, bringing friends next time. Thanks guys for being a “home made” restaurant!!!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Procopio's, and I have to express that their pizza is, without a doubt, the finest I have ever had the opportunity to savor! The pizza was cooked to absolute perfection, and I was especially impressed by the fact that the owner himself personally delivered our pizza to our table, which added a genuinely warm, personal, and charming touch to the entire dining experience. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere of the restaurant transported us back in time, creating a wonderful, quaint, and nostalgic ambiance that evoked memories of a bygone era. I wholeheartedly recommend Procopio's to anyone visiting the Vincennes area. As someone who frequently travels through Vincennes, I can confidently say that this establishment will undoubtedly become a regular stop for my family and I in the future.

I’m so happy that the locals really suggested this place! I’m from Ohio and was in Vincennes, In and I loved every bite! The calamari was crispy and fresh, the pasta was creamy and oh so good, bread crispy and salad light and fresh! I am very pleased I came here. I can’t tell the owners take pride in their business and I hope that they continue to grow! The food was great, the staff and owner were AMAZINGLY FRIENDLY, and just an overall really good experience!

We absolutely love this place. The people were friendly and very welcoming!! Really neat atmosphere. Lauren was out waitress and had a super personality!!

The stuffed pizza and calamari are the best I've had in years. Much better than anything you get in Princeton. Well worth the drive to Vincennes. Will definitely be going back again.

Procopio's Pizza & Pasta